Articles & OpinionNews

After 112 years, Franciscan nuns leave Aleppo: What does their departure reveal about Syria’s new era?

Fahed Arabi

Departure of Franciscan nuns from Aleppo after 112 years.. A reading into post-war Syria’s transformations

 

After 112 years of continuous service in the city of Aleppo, the Franciscan Missionaries of Mary nuns have ended their presence in the city, a step that goes beyond its ecclesiastical framework to open a broader discussion about the future of historic religious institutions in Syria, and the transformations that have affected the Syrian social and demographic fabric after years of war.

The departure, which the religious order announced was due to internal reorganization and redistribution of staff because of declining nun numbers, coincides with a sensitive phase in which Syria is witnessing a reshaping of the relationship between society, the state, and religious institutions.

The resonance of the decision was not limited to the departure of nuns who had worked in Aleppo for decades, but rather to what their presence represented in terms of social memory associated with education, healthcare, humanitarian work, and dialogue among the components of Aleppo’s society.

Statement of the Evangelical Church.. An ecumenical message and existential warning

Following the announcement, the National Evangelical Synod of Syria and Lebanon, represented by the Arabic Evangelical Church in Aleppo, issued an official statement signed by Reverend Ibrahim Abdul Karim Nasser, in which he described the departure as a “heavy loss for the city of Aleppo and its Christian presence,” and “another chapter in the existential challenge facing Christians in Syria.”

The statement did not treat the decision as merely an internal administrative matter, but placed it in the context of the decline in Christian presence, the emigration of families, and the shrinking of pastoral and educational institutions, calling for not closing the page in silence and keeping the issue present in ecclesiastical and ecumenical awareness.

The statement carried three fundamental implications: pointing to the loss of a historic institution, concern over the continued decline of Christian presence, and an indirect message to political authorities regarding the responsibility to preserve diversity in Syria.

Aleppo’s changing demographics.. From 300,000 to 20,000

The head of the convent, Sister Renée Koussa, announced that the decision was due to the decline in the number of nuns, coinciding with the opening of a new convent in Al-Hasakah province. However, the timing of the departure gave it additional dimensions, as it comes in a city where the Christian population was around 300,000 in 2011, declining to between 20,000 and 25,000 according to various sources.

This demographic shift is not merely a matter of individual choices, but reflects a new shaping of Syria’s population map. The departure of the nuns is not a cause of this decline, but it is a clear indicator of its impact on institutions that depend on a stable social presence to maintain their activities.

Repositioning, not withdrawal.. Al-Hasakah and the Salesians

The departure does not represent a complete withdrawal of the order from Syria, but rather a reorganization of presence, with the opening of a convent in Al-Hasakah, where the order sees greater potential for continuing its mission in an area with a diverse composition, albeit one experiencing security and political complexities.

Meanwhile, the Salesian order will take over some of the educational and social services and activities that were already in place, meaning a partial continuation of humanitarian work. However, this transition of roles does not erase the symbolic value of the Franciscan presence; the relationship they built with Aleppo’s society over more than a century cannot be replaced by an administrative transfer, as historic institutions are measured not only by their services, but by the accumulated trust they have built over time.

Franciscan nuns' departure: from Aleppo to Al-Hasakah
Preacher lad, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Between shelling and political promises.. A test of credibility

The nuns’ departure came at a time when religious institutions were facing security repercussions, with the broader regional context of the US-Iran war affecting Syria.

On December 1, 2024, the Franciscan complex at the Terra Sancta College in Aleppo was hit by an airstrike, causing damage to one wing, the warehouse, and facilities, but no casualties were reported.

Despite the monks’ statement rejecting violence and calling for the protection of institutions, the absence of an official response regarding the targeting raised questions about the authorities’ ability to provide effective protection. This was not the first such attack; in 2015, a mortar shell struck St. Francis Church during an evening mass, causing minor injuries and material damage.

On December 31, 2024, transitional President Ahmad al-Sharaa met with a delegation of Christian clerics and made promises to protect Christians and facilitate their return, saying: “I would like all Christians to return here. This is their land, and we will ensure their safety, protection, and freedom.”

However, the ongoing demographic shifts and the departure of an institution of this historical depth put these statements before a practical test of the official discourse’s ability to produce a stable reality, reflecting the concerns evident in the church’s statement.

A model of practical dialogue and an eight-century legacy

The Franciscans represent a rare model of practical dialogue, based not on conferences but on joint work in daily life, as described by Father Firas Lutfi: “Hand in hand, heart to heart.” This model was evident in child care projects in east Aleppo in cooperation with the Muslim community, and in the distribution of aid without discrimination. The nuns’ departure may mean the loss of part of this social model based on daily interaction and accumulated trust.

The Franciscan presence in Syria is not limited to the last century, but extends for more than 800 years. The Custodial Vicar, Father Ibrahim Faltas, noted that about two thousand monks have lost their lives over the centuries while serving people and protecting heritage, and that the order has faced kidnapping and targeting but has continued its presence. This historical legacy gives any change in their presence implications that go beyond the size of the institution, relating to the future of diversity in Syria.

Who invests in the nuns’ departure? Open questions

The departure of the Franciscan nuns cannot be reduced to an internal administrative decision, nor can it be made a single indicator of the end of Christian presence. The event lies at the intersection of three paths: an official path that may view it as a natural redistribution of institutions; an ecclesiastical path that sees it in the context of declining Christian presence and family emigration; and a media path that some may use as a symbol in the struggle over the vision of the new Syria.

However, the fundamental question remains open: Is this merely a repositioning of a historic institution, or part of a larger transformation in the shape of religious and social presence in post-war Syria? The void left by an institution after 112 years is measured not by the number of its workers, but by the volume of trust and relationships it built over decades.

While the nuns’ departure does not provide a definitive answer, it poses a broader test for the new Syria, at a time when reports on the coastal and Suwayda regions point to the fragility of official reassurance. This raises further questions: Can the transitional government protect this diversity, or will the repositioning of historic institutions become a hallmark of this phase? And what are the dimensions of political investment in this file amid regional conflict?

Ultimately, the real bet is not on the survival of a single institution, but on the survival of the idea it represented: that diversity is not preserved by statements alone, but by an environment capable of protecting and sustaining it.


Read also:

Trump meets al-Sharaa in Ankara, discusses Hezbollah file and sanctions relief for Syria

قيم هذا المقال | Rate this post

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button